Man made video before woman's death, court hears
Family handoutA man accused of murdering a woman he met on a fetish website shot a video of her before her death in which he ordered her to repeat that she wanted to be beaten and made to suffer, a court in the United States has heard.
Dwain Hall, whose online user name was Alpha Sadist, is accused of the kidnap and murder of 32-year-old Sonia Exelby, from Southsea in Hampshire.
The recovered footage, which had been deleted from Hall's phone, was played to the Florida court where the 54-year-old is on trial.
The jury had previously heard from prosecutors that Hall was a predator who had manipulated his mentally ill victim and then stabbed her to death "for his own sadistic pleasure". Hall denies the charges.
Warning: This article contains distressing details
Sonia Exelby, who the court was told had a history of self-harm and wanted to die, was reported missing from her home on 12 October last year, by which time police established she had left the country.
Her buried body was found by US investigators in Marion County, Florida, on 17 October.
In the deleted video, which was entered into evidence, Hall can be heard directing her to say why she was there and why she is "such an awful person".
In response, she says she has "crushed everyone who ever loves me".
Hall says: "How did you want to die? What was your chosen way to die? Kind of describe that. What have you been consenting to here today?"
She says: "You mean the way that you're talking about killing me? Yeah, is that what you mean?"
After a delay, she says: "Be stabbed."
Hall responds: "Yeah, that's what you want. But the last day or two, what has your treatment been? What did you ask for leading up to that?"
She says: "I can't remember. We talked about so many different ways."
Hall says: "What's this on your face?"
She replies: "You've beaten me."
Hall then asks "is that what you wanted?", to which she replies "yes".
'A big storm'
The court also heard on Thursday that Hall told a friend there "might be a big storm coming for me" before sending him a package containing a knife later found to have Sonia Exelby's blood on it.
The trial was shown a series of Facebook messages exchanged between the defendant and Rick Snyder last October prior to the discovery of Sonia Exelby's body.
In them, Hall asks his friend for his address in Ohio.
In the exchanges, Hall refuses to go into detail saying "can't tell you here. Lease (sic) I say the better," and also indicated his phone "may be tapped".
Hall wrote in a message that he would need the contents back in six months "if this storm passes over with no lingering fallout".
He said: "Please, for the love of shadows, don't lose this box. There's no need to even open it. These are very precious and valuable personal items."
After Snyder promised to keep it safe, Hall thanked him and told him to contact his wife, Ginger, about their return in six months "just in case this storm is as bad as expected".
In subsequent messages the day before Sonia Exelby's body was found on October 17, Snyder notes in a message that Hall is "jumpy", to which the defendant says it was because the box contained "two of my most prized possessions".
Following the discovery of the messages on Hall's phone and the UPS label, investigators travelled to Washington county in Ohio, where local detectives executed a search warrant at Snyder's property on 4 November, 2025.
The contents of the package were found inside a cloth bag in the dresser of Snyder's bedroom, the court heard.
It included a knife in a sheath and a bracelet that belonged to Hall, the jury was told.
Giving evidence at the trial, a crime laboratory biologist said both Hall and Sonia Exelby were "possible contributors" to a mixed DNA profile found on the bracelet.
Hall, Exelby and Snyder were also found to be "possible contributors" to DNA found the knife sheath, the court heard.
The jury was shown a picture of the black knife.
The criminal biologist told the trial she had taken a sample from staining under the handle, which she tested for blood.
She said it gave "chemical indications for the presence of blood", and she then took it forward for DNA testing.
She said Hall was "excluded as the source" and then told the court: "The DNA profile matched the DNA profile from Sonia Exelby."
At the start of Thursday's proceedings, the jury was shown data from the Life360 location sharing app, which prosecutors said tracked Hall's movements over a number of days last October.
This included a time spent on 12 October at the burial site where Sonia Exelby's body was eventually found days later.
It also showed he had visited the Ocala branch of Lowe's, a US DIY chain, earlier the same day, where he was seen on security camera footage buying a large tarpaulin.
The court has already heard Hall had bought a shovel and rope shortly before Sonia Exelby's arrival.
Giving evidence to the court, a clinical neuropsychologist described Exelby's level of vulnerability as "exceptionally high".
Earlier, a police digital forensic examiner told the court he had found images of rape, torture and murder on Hall's phone.
The jury previously heard that after the discovery of Sonia Exelby's body, she was found to have been stabbed four times in the left side, with wounds up to seven inches deep.
The jury also watched a lengthy video of Hall being questioned by investigators in which he initially denied knowing her, before eventually making a full retraction to "clear my conscience".
He claimed he had been reluctant to share details about her because he had promised not to.
He told the law enforcement officers he had been "mentoring" the 32-year-old online, "wanted to make her life better" and he did not want her to kill herself.
His previous statements, later recanted, had been "Sonia's cover story", according to Hall.
He added: "She insisted that she did not want to be a burden to me or my wife in the process of getting her needs met.
"I was very appreciative of that, and I just wanted to help her."
Hall told investigators: "She just didn't want to be disturbed any more. After she came here, she wanted that to be it."
He went on: "She did not want to be found. She did not want to be returned home."
The trial continues.
- If you have been affected by issues raised in this story, you can visit the BBC Action Line for support and information
