Sunderland 0-2 Arsenal: How the players ratedpublished at 23:31 BST 12 September
Alex Brotherton
BBC Sport journalist
Sunderland starting XI:
Robin Roefs: Poor distribution - two goal-kicks went straight out of play. Hardly troubled in the first half but made a fine save to tip over Kai Havertz's acrobatic effort. 6
Thomas Meunier: Offered a threat on second balls from set pieces but couldn't covert a couple of half chances. Tracked back to help defensively. 6
Nordi Mukiele: Kept Christos Tzolis quiet and provided a good outlet on break, but didn't pick out the right passes. Weak shot when right in front of goal at 1-0 down. Forced David Raya into saves with two late chances but should have scored the second. 6
Kevin Danso: An unspectacular but assured home debut. 6
Dan Ballard: Defensively solid as ever and coped well with Arsenal's press. Should have scored from Xhaka free-kick, but won a penalty. 7
Reinildo Mandava: Largely contained Bukayo Saka, though was baited into fouling him and getting booked. Conceded late penalty and sent off. 4
Nilson Angulo: Lively on the wing and diligent in tracking back, but he should have run at Ben White and Ezri Konsa more. 6
Noah Sadiki: Showed willingness to get forward but also track back, but final ball lacked quality. 6
Granit Xhaka: Produced quality set-piece deliveries and busy as ever in midfield. Made a goal-saving clearance with the last kick of the first half. 7
Enzo Le Fee: Alert and always eager to drive attacks, but telegraphed his soft penalty. 6
Brian Brobbey: Made the lives of Konsa and White miserable all evening with his strength and hold-up play. Created space for others but didn't get any shots away, though that wasn't his brief tonight. 7
Sunderland substitutes:
Wilson Isidor (on 70, Angulo): 6
Malick Fofana (on 75, Meunier): 6
Subs not used: Dayann Methalie, Chemsdine Talbi, Chris Rigg, Luke O'Nien, Omar Alderete, Melker Ellborg, Trai Hulme.































