Lyon are a formidable opponent in the Champions League this season and appear determined to get their hands on the ninth title they missed out on in May when they lost 4-0 to Barcelona in the final.
They are yet to concede a goal in the competition in the league phase and have netted an incredible 22 goals in their five matches.
It was always going to be a challenge for Arsenal to get the three points they needed to help secure automatic qualification - and it looks unlikely they will do so, given a three-point gap to Chelsea, who are in fourth place, with Manchester City fifth.
The Gunners must beat Inter Milan in their final game and hope results go in their favour elsewhere to overturn a goal difference swing.
They were on the back foot from the first whistle on Thursday night as Lyon's quality overawed them and the visitors played with intensity and creativity.
The individual brilliance of Dumornay and Lily Yohannes was evident and they were impressively stylish on the attack, missing a few chances to confirm their dominance.
Marie-Antoinette Katoto fired over from close range and Yohannes curled just wide to give Arsenal hope going into the break and they came out at the start of the second half with much more bite.
England striker Alessia Russo's shot was blocked in the six-yard area and Caitlin Foord almost escaped in behind a few times, but couldn't make it count.
However, that period was short-lived as Dumornay's powerful strike gave Lyon the cushion they needed and it was difficult for the hosts to regain a foothold back in the game.
The defeat capped a challenging period for the Gunners in which they were held to a draw in the Women's Super League by London City Lionesses on Sunday, after working hard for a draw in Barcelona last week.